I go for the top one. When spinning the white along the edge of the bottom one may bleed into the other colors. The color separation on the top blade looks like it will remain separated while spinning. Different colors that run the length of the blade tend to "blend" when spinning and become some other color, while colors separated across the blade will remain separated. Put it on the line and spin it to see the difference between the two, that will help you decide. This came from a book I read by a retired Mack's lure designer.2cents