I have had a scotty bb on 2 boats but not on my present boat. Now, I have replaced the wire cable with braided which doesn't work for a bb. I have done just as well w/o the bb. From my years of using the bb both in fresh & salt, I think it is more helpful in the salt. If you have a "hot boat" situation that can't be resolved, a bb may be necessary. Another thing I found with the bb looking at my finder is that fish would be attracted all up & down the length of the cable...not just in the area of my depth setting. For whatever reason I do just as well as when I had the bb which I used almost 5 yrs. And, I don't miss the cable. The braid doesn't "sing", it doesn't kink, it doesn't corrode, it has less "blowback" and conectiions can be made with simple knots rather than crimping. BTW, I have a scotty bb (the best from what I have heard) for $75 if anyone's interested. Probably just talked you out of it?