Two things I might try. The first is to make sure I have a stinger hook behind my rig. This will ensure that there is plenty of opportunity for him not to miss a connection. The second thing would be to play with the leader length. When using a hoochie, it is necessary to keep the leader relatively short in order to create movement in the lure. But when using a more traditional lure, the leader length is far less critical to the action of the lure. This leader length can make a difference in the caution of the fish however. If the leader is too short, this can cause fish to be bashful of the lure and cause "short strikes" that will have a tendancy to either break leaders or miss strikes. If the leader is too long, this will allow the fish to be too comfortable and they will be more likely to mouth the lure and as a result, never really even let you know they were there, or at least not until it is too late.
I don't know that these are things that would have helped you to catch your fish but they are the things I would have tried. The stinger hook idea has really paid off for me when trolling and I try to gear all of my trolling rigs that way now no matter what the species I am pursuing.