Hey Ricks
What are the "pops" your are describing? I'm new to kokanee fishing and not familiar with the gear. Also what was the purple lure the guy you talked to using?
Are you using shoepeg corn with the scents?
Sorry about the barrage of questions, but we fish our butts off and have yet to catch a limit.
Pop gear is the trolling flashers. They can be all shapes sizes and colors. Some days, bigger or more aggressive 'bite' can sometimes mean a big difference. Ford fenders thrash the water harder than willow blades, believe me when I say that is both good and terrible at times. If the fish are nervous, pop gear that makes a lot of noise is likely to keep them away. Sometimes the fish are especially aggressive and you find that works best. Other times, I use small handmade trolls with 2, 4, 5 or even 6 small spinners on it.If the fish are being tentative, I will always toss one on a line to test the theory.
Sometimes I'll even use bigger pop gear and attach them directly to the downrigger ball. Then I use a release attached about 3-6 feet above the pop gear and hang just a lure by itself 6 feet behind the pop gear and 3 feet above it Since I have a gas powered trolling motor this usually only works when the fishing is 40 or more feet down. Works great on big trout near the bottom of a lake!
Unfortunately, the only way to get good at this is to own a lot of gear and try a lot of it out whenever the fishing is slow. For me, I wish I could say with a straight face that I always catch a lot of kokanee. NOT!. I have met some who seem able to catch em in any conditions, but I ain't one of em. I will work my way through my gear boxes trying different things until I wear out my welcome. I have always said a well outfitted kokanee boat has as much gear as a japanese fishing trawler. Gotta have lots of colors, several different levels of aggressiveness, and as good electronics as you can afford.
Last tip is never leave fish to find fish. Once you find a spot and start hitting kokes, hammer em. I'm guilty of being more curious about another fishing spot, which means I don't always catch the obvious fish.
And yeah, I use shoepeg corn soaked overnight in various concoctions. I also will use berkely fake maggots. And sometimes just plain ol worm on my spinner. I often try the different
ProTroll 'kokanee killer' lures, but I seldom have much success no matter how good they look to my eyes.
Edit, I never saw whatever the loner was using as his purple lure. I don't think it would matter much. The color is probably more important than the type. I only had one purple handmade spinner in the boat, we tried it fort a while but it was less reliable for us than chrome and red or pinks.